EDP Sciences
Free Access
Issue
A&A
Volume 550, February 2013
Article Number A113
Number of page(s) 12
Section Extragalactic astronomy
DOI https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201219700
Published online 04 February 2013

© ESO, 2013

1. Introduction

Compact symmetric objects (CSOs) are a subclass of extragalactic radio sources that are characterized by a compact double or triple radio structure with an overall size of less than 1 kpc. The physical nature of the compactness of CSOs is still a question under debate: the youth model (e.g. Phillips et al. 1982; Fanti et al. 1995; Readhead et al. 1996) proposes that CSOs are small because they are in the infant stage of the extragalactic radio source evolution; the frustration model (e.g. van Breugel et al. 1984; O’Dea et al. 1991) attributes the small size of CSOs to extremely strong confinement by the dense external medium. The two models define distinctly different evolutionary fates of CSOs. In the youth model, all young CSOs eventually evolve into large-scale double sources, i.e., Fanaroff-Riley (FR, Fanaroff & Riley 1974) type-II sources, over a few million years; whereas according to the frustration model, CSOs are confined within the host galaxy and experience stagnated growth. The CSO ages provide a critical distinction between the two models. Previous kinematics studies of individual CSOs and subsamples of these sources (e.g. Owsianik & Conway 1998; Owsianik et al. 1998; Taylor et al. 2000; Gugliucci et al. 2005; An et al. 2012) show that the measured hotspot advancing speed values have a large scatter from  ~0.04   c to  ~0.5   c, resulting in young kinematic ages in the range of only 100–2000 yr. However, additional sideways motions of hotspots and disturbed lobes indicate strong interactions between the jet heads and the surrounding interstellar medium (Stanghellini et al. 2009; An et al. 2012). Sideways motion is usually very slow compared to the dominant advancing motion, which requires highly accurate measurements. A detailed investigation of well-selected CSO samples is essential for exploring the complex kinematics of CSOs, and for understanding the physical environment of the host galaxies on 1–500 pc scales.

The kinematic age (τk) of CSOs is traditionally determined by dividing the separation (R) between two terminal hotspots by the separation rate (μ). A high-accuracy measurement of τk requires high-precision position determination for individual observations, and a sufficiently long timespan of the data. For more than two epochs, μ is often determined from a linear regression fit to the changing hotspot separation with time. The statistical uncertainty of the fit is sensitive to the number of available data points and the uniformity of the time sampling. In addition to this, different resolutions of the interferometric images and the intrinsic opacity effect in different levels may introduce systematic errors in the proper motion measurements. An accurate measurement for the separation rate μ requires CSOs with multiple-epoch Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) imaging data at the same observing frequency over a sufficiently long time span.

In this paper, we carry out a kinematic study of an archetypal CSO, OQ 208, on the basis of archival VLBI data over a time baseline of 13.6 yr. OQ 208 (also known as Mrk 668, B1404+286) is one of the closest CSOs (z = 0.0766: Huchra et al. 1990) and provides a template for the dynamic properties of the most compact (and possibly the youngest) radio sources. The host galaxy of OQ 208 shows typical Seyfert-1 spectra with strong broad Balmer lines (FWHMHα = 6000 km s-1) and also forbidden lines of [Ne III], [O III] and [S II] (Burbidge & Strittmatter 1972; Eracleous & Halpern 1994). In the radio band, a broad 21-cm Hi absorption line was detected in OQ 208, indicating a fast and massive outflow of neutral gas (Morganti et al. 2005). The radio emission is concentrated in a compact central region within  ~10 mas (Stanghellini et al. 1997). Additional evidence for the compactness comes from the convex radio spectrum with a turnover at about 4.9 GHz (Dallacasa et al. 2000), resulting from synchrotron self-absorption or free-free absorption (Fanti 2009). The VLBI images of OQ 208 at 2.3 and 5 GHz reveal a typical CSO-type morphology with two compact (mini-)lobes along the NE–SW direction (Stanghellini et al. 1997; Liu et al. 2000; Wang et al. 2003). At higher frequencies of 8 and 15 GHz, a more detailed structure is revealed: the mini-lobes are resolved into subcomponents, and internal jet knots are detected between the two lobes (Kellermann et al. 1998; Luo et al. 2007) Previous proper motion measurements of OQ 208 (e.g. Liu et al. 2000; Stanghellini et al. 2002; Wang et al. 2003; Luo et al. 2007) were mostly based on 5- and 8-GHz data with lower angular resolutions and are affected by the opacity effect. Moreover, these measurements only cover a time span of a few years, insufficient for tracing the long-term change of the hotspots. In the present study, we only made use of 15-GHz VLBI data to determine the separation velocities of hotspots and the proper motions of the internal jet knots.

The structure of the paper is as follows. Section 2 describes the VLBI data used for the kinematics study. Section 3 presents the results, including radio images, light curves, and proper motion measurements. A conclusion and a summary are given in Sect. 4. Throughout this paper, we assume a flat cosmological model with H0 = 73 km s-1 Mpc-1, ΩM = 0.27, ΩΛ = 0.73. At the redshift of OQ 208, 1 mas angular size corresponds to 1.4 pc projected linear size, and a proper motion of 1 mas yr-1 corresponds to 4.9 c apparent speed.

2. VLBI data

Owing to its compactness and high brightness, OQ 208 is often used as a calibrator in VLBI experiments. Consequently, there are abundant archival VLBI data sets from the past two decades. The 15-GHz VLBA data from the Monitoring of Jets in Active Galaxies with VLBA Experiments (MOJAVE) program1 have the highest resolution and sensitivity and are most appropriate for kinematic studies. The 15-GHz data spread over 28 epochs in the time range from early 1995 to the middle of 2009. We also made use of the VLBI data from the Radio Reference Frame Image Database (RRFID)2, which were obtained with the VLBA together with several geodetic radio telescopes simultaneously at 2.3 and 8.4 GHz. The multiple-frequency data were used for the spectral index analysis of compact components. The RRFID data cover the time range from 1994 to 2008.

The calibration of the archival VLBI data has already been made in the Astronomical Image Processing System (AIPS) following the standard procedure. We performed additionally several iterations of self-calibration in DIFMAP (Shepherd et al. 1994) to eliminate residual antenna-based phase errors. The 15-GHz visibilities were fitted with five Gaussian model components (two in the northwest lobe, another two in the southeast lobe, and one jet knot, see Fig. 1) using the DIFMAP task MODELFIT. Table 1 lists the fitted parameters, including the integrated flux density Si, the relative separation R from the primary hotspot used as the reference, the position angle of the VLBI component, and the deconvolved size θmaj × θmin. The statistical uncertainties of the observed parameters were estimated according to the formulae given by Fomalont (1999), except that we also included an additional 5% as the amplitude calibration error. The details of the error analysis method are given by An et al. (2012).

In addition to VLBI imaging data, the single-dish flux density monitoring data observed with the 26-m paraboloid telescope of the University of Michigan Radio Astronomical Observatory3 (Aller et al. 1985) were included for a supplementary analysis of the variability and the geometry of the radio structure. The total flux density measurements were made at 4.8, 8, and 14.5 GHz from July 1974 to August 2009.

thumbnail Fig. 1

Total intensity image of OQ 208. Panel a) shows the 2.3-GHz VLBI image, displaying a double-component morphology. Panel b) shows the tapered 2.3-GHz image. The extended emission at  ~30 mas west of the primary structure is likely a relic radio emission resulting from the past activity a few thousand years ago. Panels c) and d) show the 8.4 and 15 GHz images. Each mini-lobe is resolved into two hotspots. Between the hotspots NE1 and SW1, a knotty jet is detected.

Open with DEXTER

3. Results

3.1. Radio morphology

At 2.3 GHz, OQ 208 exhibits the double-component morphology typical of the CSOs (Fig. 1a). The total extent of the radio source is about 7 mas (~10 pc). The northeast (NE) component is much brighter than the southwest (SW) one with an intensity ratio of 18.0:1 at 2.3 GHz. Both components show a steep spectral index at high frequencies (defined as S ∝ να) with (SW) and (NE), identifying them as two mini-lobes of the CSO. The asymmetric brightness of two-sided jets/lobes in radio sources is commonly attributed to the Doppler boosting effect that enhances the apparent flux density of the advancing jet/lobe by a factor of δ3 + α, where δ is the Doppler boosting factor and α is the spectral index. However, the kinematic analysis below suggests that the jet in OQ 208 is mildly relativistic and the jets nearly align with the plane of the sky, therefore Doppler boosting cannot account for the brightness difference. Another explanation of the strong asymmetry in the brightness of the two lobes is that the receding SW lobe suffers from more free-free absorption than the advancing NE lobe. Indeed, the flux density ratio is even higher at a lower frequency of 1.66 GHz, SNE/SSW = 60:1 (Kameno et al. 2000), supporting this interpretation. A third possibility is that the inhomogeneous distribution of the external medium surrounding the lobes results in a larger conversion efficiency from jet kinetic energy to radiative energy in the northeast jet (Orienti & Dallacasa 2012).

A 2.3-GHz image with a Gaussian taper with a half-value at 20 Mλ wavelength (Fig. 1b) reveals an extended feature about 30 mas (~40 pc) to the west, which was previously reported by Luo et al. (2007). Extended emission features on kpc to Mpc scales has also been detected in OQ 208 (de Bruyn 1990) and in other CSO galaxies (e.g., 0108+388: Baum et al. 1990; Stanghellini et al. 2005; 0941-080, 1345+125: Stanghellini et al. 2005), which were interpreted as relics remaining from past (>108 yr ago) nuclear activity. Extended components on scales of  <100 pc are rarely seen in CSOs (J1511+0518 is another example; Orienti & Dallacasa 2008) and this puzzling one-sided extended feature at 40 pc distance requires an interval between two intermittent activities shorter than 2 × 103 yr (Orienti & Dallacasa 2008). The non-detection of the northeast fading lobe likely indicates asymmetric properties of the ambient interstellar medium (ISM) on pc scales, leading to more rapid radiative or adiabatic losses and a shorter life of the NE lobe. This, again, is consistent with the fact that the NE advancing lobe is much brighter.

The NE lobe is resolved into two subcomponents (NE1 and NE2) at 8 and 15 GHz. NE1 dominates the flux density of the whole source. The spectral index of NE1, determined from 8 and 15 GHz data at close epochs, is . The brightness temperature is calculated using the equation (1)where Sob is the observed flux density in Jy, νob is the observing frequency in GHz, θmaj and θmin are the major and minor axis of the Gaussian model component in units of mas, and Tb is the derived brightness temperature in source rest frame in units of Kelvin. The average brightness temperature of NE1 is 4.4 × 1010 K. The secondary component NE2 is weaker than NE1 in the range 4.3–16.3. It has a lower brightness temperature of 1.4 × 109 K and a much steeper spectral index of . The high brightness temperature and the relatively flatter spectral index of NE1 identify it as the primary hotspot formed by the reverse shock when the jet head impacts on the wall of the external medium. The continuous emission structure between NE1 and NE2 would suggest a physical connection.

The SW lobe is resolved into two components (SW1 and SW2) at 8 and 15 GHz. The two components have comparable sizes. The integrated flux density of SW1 is slightly higher than SW2 with a flux density ratio R(SW1/SW2) in the range of 1.3−2.4. Their spectral indices are   ±  0.07 (SW1) and 1.82  ±  0.26 (SW2).

The presence of double hotspots in the 10-pc lobe structure of OQ 208 remains a puzzle. Similar morphology is found in the multiple-hotspot appearance of large-scale double sources such as 3C 20 (Laing 1981; Hardcastle & Looney 2001), where the hotspot usually identified as the primary hotspot is extremely compact and bright, and the other is more diffuse and shows various structures. Three models may account for the double hotspots inside the 10-pc nuclear region of OQ208:

  • (1)

    Blocking of the jet head by the external medium. In this scenario, the jet impacts on the wall of the surrounding medium and generates the hotspot there. As the jet head may slide along the wall, the hotspot position also changes accordingly (dentist’s drill model: Scheuer 1982). The primary hotspot is the currently active jet-ISM interaction, while the secondary hotspot represents the past primary hotspot, which is now fading away.

  • (2)

    Jet precession. The present images do not allow us to distinguish whether a single jet beam is precessing (Cox et al. 1991) or if there are intrinsically two beams (Laing 1982) due to the similar compactness and shape of two hotspots and the absence of emission between the hotspots and the nucleus. One possible driving mechanism of jet precession is associated with a binary black hole system where the black hole launching the jet has a relative motion with respect to the surrounding ISM and the multiple hotspots reflect the different impact locations. Taking the brighter SW1 as the primary (current) and SW2 as the secondary (older) impact of the jet beam(s) on the external medium, the older hotspot has stopped receiving direct energy supply from the nucleus, and synchrotron aging will result in a steeper radio spectrum at high frequencies. Indeed, SW2 has a steeper spectral index than SW1. If SW2 is the old hotspot, it should lie behind the primary hotspot SW1, implying that there is a jet bending between SW2 and SW1.

  • (3)

    Redirected flows. Alternatively, the secondary hotspot represents either a re-directed outflow originating from the primary hotspot (Laing 1981) or a deflected jet flow (Lonsdale & Barthel 1986) escaping from a weak point in the cocoon/lobe structure. Different from the model (1), the secondary hotspot in model (3) continues to receive energy supply from the primary hotspot. Therefore, it would last longer, would not show spectral steepening, and be much fainter and less compact than the primary hotspot. In the eastern lobe, NE2 has no direct connection with the nucleus, but shows a collimated bridge that links it with NE1. NE2 is also larger than NE1 and has an amorphous shape. These morphological characters make NE2 more likely to be the result of a re-directed outflow from the primary hotspot NE1 than a directed flow from the nucleus.

The continuous emission between two hotspots NE1 and SW1 at 2.3-GHz (Fig. 1a) is resolved into a knotty jet at 8.4 and 15 GHz (Figs. 1c and 1d). From east to west, these knots are labeled J1, J2, J3, and J4. J1 is the brightest jet knot located at the inlet of the northeast lobe and is detected at 15 and 8.4 GHz at all epochs. It has a 15 GHz to 8.4 GHz spectral index between 0.81 and 1.45, indicative of a typical optically thin jet knot, and a brightness temperature of 3.4 × 109 K. J2 appears in the 8.4-GHz images at epochs from 2002.044 to 2002.945, where the VLBI images have the highest sensitivity and resolution. J2 only appears in the most sensitive 15-GHz image at epochs 1995.958, 1996.378, 2003.318, 2008137, and 2009.558. It has a steep spectrum with and a brightness temperature Tb ≤ 1.9 × 107 K. J3 is closest to the geometric center and only appears in the highest sensitivity 15-GHz images. The brightness temperature of J3 is  ≤ 3.0 × 107 K derived from the 15-GHz data. Lacking the spectral index information, the active nucleus or the innermost jet knot nature of J3 remains uncertain. Regardless of the identification of J3, the non-detection at 8.4 GHz would imply an extremely high absorption opacity toward the nucleus. J4 is only marginally detected at 15 GHz on 2009.558. More sensitive observations are necessary to to reveal the physical nature of these components.

thumbnail Fig. 2

Variability of VLBI components of OQ 208. a) Total flux density variability of OQ 208 observed with the UMRAO 26-meter radio telescope: 4.8 GHz (black), 8 GHz (red), 14.5 GHz (blue). The sum of 15-GHz flux densities of the VLBI components (see Table 1) is represented by green symbols indicating that  ~15% is missed due to lack of short uv-spacings. b) Temporal variations of the flux densities of VLBI components. The flux densities are derived from the model-fitting results listed in Table 1. Two vertical lines mark the peak epochs of NE1 (around 1998.313) and SW1 (around 2003.313). To clearly show the variability behavior of SW1, the flux densities of SW1 have been multiplied by a factor of 10. c) Variation of the 15-GHz flux density of the hotspot NE1 with the component size. The flux density of NE1 experienced a slow rise before epoch 1998.313, followed again by a sharp decline until epoch 2005.473 followed by a slow decline. The component size constantly increases during the whole period. d) Temporal variation of the spectral index of the NE lobe. The spectral indices are calculated from the 15-GHz MOJAVE data and 8-GHz RRFID data at close epochs. A sharp jump of the spectral index occurs around 2006, after which the spectral index steepens significantly.

Open with DEXTER

3.2. Variability of the hotspot NE1

The steep-spectrum lobes dominate the total flux density of most CSOs. Fassnacht & Taylor (2001) monitored a sample of seven CSOs using the VLA at 8.5 GHz and found extremely stable flux densities (rms variability less than 1%) over a period of eight months. Some exceptional CSOs show moderate-level variability on time scales of a few years, for example, OQ 208 (the present paper) and J1324+4048 (An et al. 2012). Unlike with blazars with a jet luminosity amplified by Doppler boosting, the low- and moderate-level variability observed in lobe-dominated CSOs is probably related to variation of the energy supply by the relativistic jet flow and the changes of the energy dissipation process including the adiabatic expansion losses and radiative losses.

The light curves observed with the Michigan 26-m radio telescope (UMRAO) at three frequencies (4.8, 8, and 14.5 GHz) show two distinct flares in the past 25 years, around 1983 and 2000 (Fig. 2a). The accurate peak epoch around 1983 cannot be clearly determined because of the broad gap in the sampling, while the second-peak epoch is not well constrained because the light curves only cover the declining part of the flare. The 5-GHz flux density variation of OQ 208 using the VLA Stanghellini et al. (1997) shows a continuous decrease from 1980 to 1995. In addition, Waltman et al. (1991) observed a decrease of the 8.1-GHz flux density from about 2.7 Jy in mid-1983 to about 2.0 Jy in mid-1989 using the Green Bank Interferometer. Starting from 1989, the flux density has been constant around 1.9 Jy. This evidence consistently suggests that OQ 208 has intrinsic variability on time scales of a few years.

For completeness, the 15-GHz summed flux densities of the VLBI components were added to diagrams covering the time range between July 1995 and August 2009, which confirms the second flare peak between 1998 and 2000. The declining part of the VLBI flux density data is fully consistent with the total flux density data. The comparison of the VLBI and single-dish data also suggests that a significant percentage (>85%) of the total flux density originates from the compact radio structure.

To quantitatively evaluate the variability, we introduced a variability index V to illustrate the relative variability scale (Zhao et al. 2012): (2)where Smax, Smin are the maximum and minimum flux density of an individual flare. A value of V ≈ 0 represents indistinguishable or undetectable variability, and V ≈ 1 indicates an extreme variability The 15-GHz light curves of individual components (Fig. 2b) suggest a high-variability index V = 0.62 ± 0.12 for NE1 during the 1998 flare and a mild V = 0.19 ± 0.04 for SW1 during the 2003 flare. The standard deviation of the measured flux densities with respect to the mean value is adopted as the statistical error. The variability index of NE1 derived from VLBI data is consistent with that measured from the single-dish monitoring data (Fig. 2a), confirming that the total flux density variation is dominated by the brightest hotspot NE1. The other VLBI components do not show significant variability at 15 GHz.

The variability at 8 and 14.5 GHz using the single-dish data (Fig. 2a) indicates a maximum level of (22 ± 4)% and (40 ± 8)%, respectively. The 5-GHz variability scale is lower than at 8 and 14.5 GHz, probably because of the increasing opacity at lower frequencies. The mini-lobes at 2.3 GHz based on the RRFID data did not show any prominent variability. At 1.4 GHz, the total flux density of OQ 208 increased from  ~755 mJy in 1979 to  ~854 mJy in 2001 (de Bruyn, priv. comm.), which is closely connected with the growth of the overall source size.

The complex variability behavior of OQ 208 can be understood separately in the low- and high-frequency regimes:

  • (1)

    Up to 1 GHz, the emission mostly arises from the extended structure surrounding the compact jets and lobes, which are strongly absorbed. The flux density of an opaque source can be simply expressed as Sν ∝ Tb × A, where Sν is the flux density at an optically thick frequency ν, Tb is the brightness temperature at frequency ν, and A is the surface area of the extended structure. The continuous increase of the flux density from 1.4 GHz to 335 MHz results from the (slow) growth of the overall source size as a result of the expansion of the radio jets and lobes.

  • (2)

    Above 1.4 GHz, the synchrotron radiation from the extended structure drops abruptly and the flux density is dominated by the compact hotspot, the mini-lobe, and the jet components. Arguments can be made that radiative losses play a dominant role in the energy balance of young and compact radio sources in the presence of strong (milliGauss; mG) magnetic fields (Stanghellini et al. 1997; Orienti et al. 2006; Orienti & Dallacasa 2012). The adiabatic expansion would then only lead to a decrease in the optically thin section of the spectrum. However, the source does not show prominent variability at 2.3-GHz, which could mean that the source is still opaque at this frequency and that any low-amplitude flux density variation is smeared out by the opacity effect.

  • (3)

    At frequencies above 5 GHz, the spectrum becomes optically thin and the observed variability is governed at the hotspots, i.e., the flux density from the most active jet-ISM interaction interface varies with the balance between the feeding and acceleration of fresh relativistic electrons and the radiative losses. The variation of the 15-GHz flux density with the component size (Fig. 2c) shows and increase of the flux density increases with the increasing size before the flare peak at epoch 1998.313, indicating the injection of particles, energy, and magnetic fields into the lobes. During this stage, the hotspot is still optically thick. After 1998, the intermittent feeding through the jet decreases and the hotspot continues to expand adiabatically and to become more optically thin. The strong synchrotron radiation results in a sharp decrease of the flux density from  ~900 mJy at 1998.313 to  ~400 mJy at 2005.473. Figure 2d shows the variation of the spectral index with time, using the 15-GHz MOJAVE data and 8.4-GHz RRFID data at close epochs. After the clear division around epoch 2006, the spectrum is significantly steepened. This supports the idea described above that the flux density variation of hotspot NE1 is regulated by intermittent nuclear feeding. When there are no or less fresh relativistic electrons inserted into the hotspots, the old electrons suffer from synchrotron aging, and the spectral index in the optically-thin part steepens.

Stanghellini et al. (1997) estimated the lifetime of the electrons radiating at 5 GHz assuming equipartition magnetic fields and a homogeneous spherical geometry for the hotspot. The resulting magnetic field in hotspot NE1 (component A in Stanghellini et al. 1997) is 90 mG, and an electron lifetime at 5 GHz of 25 yr. The synchrotron aging time scales with the observing frequency and the brightness temperature Tb as . Using the same arguments, the lifetime of electrons radiating at 15 GHz is about 4 yr, in agreement with the observed variability time scale of  ~15 yr (from 1983 to 1998).

3.3. Geometry of the radio structure

According to Fig. 2b, the light curve of the northeast hotspot NE1 peaks around 1998.313. The peak of the light curve of SW1 is not very prominent and falls in a broad time range between 2002 and 2005. A mediate epoch of is chosen as an estimate of the peak epoch, in which the uncertainty is represented by the scattering of the peak epoch. If the radio flux density enhancement in both hotspots is associated with the same episodic nuclear activity, the observation that the flare of NE1 is leading that of SW1 by  yr suggests that NE1 is the advancing lobe and SW1 is the receding one. The light travel time along the line of sight between the two hotspots corresponds to a radial difference of light years, or  pc. Assuming that the two lobes are symmetric relative to the core (separation  ~9.5 pc) and that both jets are ejected at the same velocity, an inclination angle of the radio structure of may be derived between the jet and the line of sight. This calculation suggests that the jet axis of OQ 208 is very close to the plane of the sky. It is supported by the observation that the jet emission at the nucleus is not Doppler boosted (Sects. 3.1 and 3.4).

However, this implication appears to be conflict with the optical spectroscopic identification of OQ 208 as a Seyfert 1 galaxy with broad Balmer emission lines (Burbidge & Strittmatter 1972). In the standard unification model for AGNs (Antonucci 1993), the Type-I AGNs should have an inclination angle less than 70° (Zhang 2005; Liu et al. 2007). Such an angle of 70° would predict a time delay between NE1 and SW1 of about 10.97 yr, for which there is no evidence in the light curves. The inconsistency between these inclination angles may suggest that the radio jet does not align with the optical axis of symmetry.

If the brightness asymmetry of the two lobes is caused by differential free-free absorption (Sect. 3.1), the physical properties of the ISM can be constrained. The spectral fit of free-free absorption gives a differential opacity Δτff = 5.3 (Kameno et al. 2000). The electron density is about 2700 cm-3 along a 1.53 pc path, assuming that the ISM surrounding the northeast and southwest lobes is homogeneous and the electron temperature is Te = 104 K. This electron density is typical for the narrow-line regions (NLR). An inhomogeneous ISM would require a higher density (in a clumpy medium) to account for the free-free absorption discrepancy.

thumbnail Fig. 3

Relative proper motions of VLBI components with respect to the brightest hotspot NE1. The proper motions of the VLBI components are determined by linear fits to the separations as a function of time. The angular separation rate is calculated as μ(J1) = −0.034 ± 0.001 mas yr-1, μ(SW1) = 0.027 ± 0.002 mas yr-1, and μ(SW2) = 0.022 ± 0.002 mas yr-1. The hotspot NE2 does not show significant proper motion.

Open with DEXTER

3.4. Kinematics and jet properties – a young radio source

Existing kinematics studies of CSOs show that the hotspot advancing speed is typically around 0.2c, and that they are young with kinematic ages of only between 100 and 2000 yr (Owsianik & Conway 1998; Owsianik et al. 1998; Polatidis & Conway 2003; Taylor et al. 2000; Gugliucci et al. 2005; An et al. 2012). In the present work, the slow proper motion of OQ 208 components are determined from making use of the long time-baseline 15-GHz VLBA data to eliminate systematic errors induced by different resolutions, different uv coverage, and different frequencies. Since the identification of the central core of OQ 208 is not certain yet, the brightest hotspot NE1 is used as the reference, and relative proper motions of other VLBI components are measured.

Figure 3 shows the variation of the distance of the VLBI components using 28 individual measurements over a time span is 13.6 yr. Linear regression was used to determine the separation rate. The positional uncertainty (σ ≈ 0.02 has) of each component at each epoch was used for weighting the individual data points (1/σ2). The fits give the separation rates 0.027 ± 0.002 mas yr-1 (0.134 ± 0.009   c, SW1–NE1), 0.022 ± 0.002 mas yr-1(0.108 ± 0.012   c, SW2–NE1) and −0.034 ± 0.001 mas yr-1(0.168 ± 0.005   c, J1–NE1). Positive velocities of SW1 and SW2 signify an advancing motion of both hotspots. The negative velocity of J1 indicates that the internal jet moves toward the terminal hotspot NE1. The separation of J1 at the first three epochs, 1995.266, 1995.395, and 1996.375, shows a strong deviation from the general trend of the data points beyond 1997. During the fitting process, double uncertainties were assigned to these data points in order to reduce their weight and thus to avoid a bias induced by these large deviations. The separation of NE2–NE1 is about 1.2 mas, and the linear regression fit did not give a significant proper motion, because NE2 shows a significant transverse motion rather than a radial motion (Fig. 4).

Liu et al. (2000) reported a first determination of the NE1−SW1 angular separation rate of 0.058 ± 0.038 mas yr-1, derived from 8.4-GHz data with only six epochs between 1994 and 1997. Subsequently, Luo et al. (2007) improved this value to 0.031 ± 0.006 mas/yr (5σ), on the basis of a longer time span (11 yr) and nine epochs. Compared to the previous 8.4-GHz work, the current proper motion measurements greatly improve the accuracy in the following ways: (1) the 15 GHz data provide a higher resolution (typically 0.8 × 0.6 mas2), while the previous measurements at 8.4 GHz had a resolution (1.3 × 1.0 mas2) that is comparable with the separation between SW1 and SW2. At 8.4-GHz the positions of SW1 and SW2 are affected by the flux density variation of the two components (mainly SW1), which is also true for the northeast lobe where the positions of NE2 and J1 are affected by the flux density and structure variations of NE1. At 15 GHz, SW1 is clearly separated from SW2. (2) The present work covers a time span of 13.6 yr, four times longer than in the earliest work by Liu et al. (2000), and  ~2.3 yr longer than that in Luo et al. (2007). (3) The data from 28 individual epochs give a better time sampling compared to the sparse sampling in previous works. (4) The 15-GHz VLBA data provide better and more uniform u,v coverage than the 8.4-GHz data.

According to the new measurement of μ = 0.027 ± 0.002 mas yr-1 for SW1–NE1 14σ detection), the kinematic age of OQ 208 is calculated as 255 ± 17 yr in the source rest frame. This age classifies OQ 208 as one of the youngest CSOs (Polatidis & Conway 2003; Gugliucci et al. 2005; Giroletti & Polatidis 2009; An et al. 2012).

Assuming equal advancing velocities for NE1 and SW1, the internal jet J1 is found to move 3.5 times faster (vJ1 = 0.23 c) than the terminal hotspots. A similar phenomenon has also been observed in other CSOs (e.g., B0710+439 and B2352+495: Taylor et al. 2000; J0132+5620: An et al. 2012). While the radio lobes sweep the ambient ISM, a jet knot moves in an excavated channel with a relatively lower ISM density.

The kinematic parameters of the OQ 208 jet derived above can be used to calculate the jet flow properties using the following equations: \arraycolsep1.75ptwhere, βapp is the apparent speed of the jet component, β is the intrinsic jet speed (both in units of c), θ is the inclination angle between the jet axis and the line of sight, Γ is the bulk Lorentz factor, and δ is the Doppler boosting factor. Taking the apparent speed of the jet knot J1 (βapp = 0.168   c) and the inclination angle (θ = 80.8°: Sect. 3.3) into account, we obtain β = 0.166   c, Γ = 1.014 and δ = 1.013. These calculations indicate a mildly relativistic flow in OQ 208. Relativistic beaming does not play a major role in determining the observed radiative and kinematic properties.

3.5. Sideways motion and frustrated jets

In addition to the advancing motion of the hotspots, OQ 208 shows evidence of sideways motion. Figure 4 displays the two-dimensional plots of the VLBI components’ relative locations. The primary hotspot NE1 is used as the reference at the (0, 0) position. The southwest hotspot SW1 in general indicates an advancing motion along the NE1–SW1 line, although during the first half of the period 1996−2003 it shows a curved trajectory. Similar to SW1, the internal jet J1 shows a general motion toward NE1, but it makes a loop-like path during this same initial period. This common feature of SW1 and J1 suggests that the reference NE1 may have followed a curved path between 1995 and 2003. If SW1 is used as the reference (plot is not shown here), NE1 indeed follows a bending trajectory, first to the north and then to the east, in a mirror-symmetric pattern with SW1−NE1. J1 follows a straight trajectory along the connecting line J1−SW1.

SW2 shows a complex and disordered motion pattern (Fig. 4), but generally it moves to the southwest along the connecting line NE1–SW2 within the past fourteen years. Wang et al. (2003) measured a proper motion of SW2 (relative to NE1) as 0.032  ±  0.020 mas yr-1 based on five-epoch 5-GHz data. Their measurement agrees with ours (μ = 0.022 ± 0.002 mas yr-1) with a much higher accuracy.

thumbnail Fig. 4

Relative right ascension and declination of the VLBI components. The primary hotspot NE1 serves as a reference position.

Open with DEXTER

The hotspot NE2 shows an apparent motion to the southwest, in an opposite direction of the jet advance. As discussed in Sect. 3.1, NE2 is likely a hotspot generated by the deflected jet hitting the wall of the surrounding ISM. While the hotspot NE1 is advancing faster than NE2, NE2 itself might be a stationary component.

The wandering of the jet heads NE1 and SW1, as well as the disturbed lobe structure with deflected jet or double hotspots, provide the signature of an obstructed jet flow. According to the frustration model, the advance motion of the radio lobes is confined by the surrounding dense ISM due to the intrinsically low jet power, or the reduction or cessation of the jet power. A critical requirement for a CSO to evolve into medium-sized symmetric objects (MSO) is that the jet remains supersonic at the interface between the ISM and intergalactic medium (IGM). Through analytic modeling of the expansion of the hotspot and cocoon, Kawakatu & Kino (2006) and Kawakatu et al. (2009) derived that the initial hotspot advance velocity should at least be 0.3c so that the CSO can evolve beyond the ISM-IGM boundary of the host galaxy. Jet flows with velocities below this threshold become subsonic before they reach the ISM-IGM boundary and have a distorted morphology.

The present data show that the radio source of OQ 208 is still growing, although the advancing velocity is low. The radio power of OQ 208 is P1.4   GHz = 1025.0 W Hz-1 without correction for the low-frequency absorption, placing it in the low-jet-power regime (An & Baan 2012). A low-power CSO like OQ 208 can relatively easily develop hydrodynamic surface instabilities in the jet, which makes the jet more likely to loss momentum. If a significant fraction of the jet momentum flux is dissipated, the jet cannot sustain the supersonic laminar flow and forms a stagnating standing shock (i.e., the location of the hotspot) and becomes flaring and diffused beyond that point. Such a flared jet is found in the CSS quasar 3C 48, which has a compact and bright hotspot about 300 parsec from the central AGN (Wilkinson et al. 1991; Worrall et al. 2004; Feng et al. 2005; An et al. 2010). The decrease of jet power can happen in any stage of the radio source evolution when the nuclear activity is reduced or terminated, or the jet experiences significant loss of kinetic energy because of jet-ISM interactions (An & Baan 2012). Frustrated sources may continue to grow but they do not have compact symmetric lobes. Eventually, frustrated CSOs and MSOs become radio relics at frequencies below a few hundred MHz.

4. Conclusions and summary

Multi-frequency multi-epoch radio images of OQ 208 with the highest angular resolution of  ~0.5 mas present a typical CSO morphology with two compact mini-lobes along a position angle about −126° and separated by  ~10 pc. The flux density ratio of the structural components varies with the observing frequency. At 8.4- and 15-GHz images, each lobe is resolved into two subcomponents, among which the brightest components are identified as the primary hotspots. In the highest-resolution 15-GHz images, a knotty jet is detected between the NE and SW lobes. The core of OQ 208 cannot be securely identified from the present data.

The two primary hotspots NE1 and SW1 show significant flux density variations at 15 GHz of 62% and 19%, respectively. The 15-GHz variability of the hotspots in OQ 208 may result from the balance between feeding from the central engine and adiabatic expansion loss.

The peak epoch of the NE1 flare in 1998.3 is earlier than that of the SW1 flare by an estimated 5.00 yr, suggesting that NE1 is moving toward the observer and SW1 is receding. This light travel time difference between the two hotspots corresponds to a radial distance difference of about 1.53 pc. Combining the projected and radial separation between NE1 and SW1, we estimate the inclination angle between the radio jet and the line of sight to be  ~80.8°. This value is higher than the 70° opening angle generally assumed for the nuclear NLR, which suggest that the jet axis and the galaxy axis are not aligned.

Using the brightest hotspot NE1 as the reference, the relative proper motions were estimated for SW1, SW2, and J1 to be 0.027 mas yr-1, 0.022 mas yr-1, and −0.034 mas yr-1. The separation speed between SW1 and NE1 corresponds to a hotspot advancing speed of 0.065   c, assuming symmetric advancing and receding hotspot motions. The proper motion of the jet component J1 relative to the systemic center is about −0.047 mas yr-1 and corresponds to a velocity of 0.230 c, making the jet mildly relativistic. The internal jet knot moves significantly faster than the terminal hotspots because it encounters a lower density in the excavated jet channel than the hotspots within the lobes. The angular separation rate leads to an estimate of the kinematic age of about 255 yr, suggesting that OQ 208 is one of the youngest CSOs known.

The observed sideways motion of hotspots and disturbed lobe morphology are signatures of obstruction of the jet head by the surrounding ISM, although the overall radio source is still growing. During the early CSO stages of a radio source evolution, such disturbed lobe structures seem common (An et al. 2012). A young radio source may experience intermittent jet power or several failed starts before entering into a continuous and steady growth phase. During each intermittent activity, the jets may impact different regions of the ISM, failing to make a breakthrough. The notion of intermittent energy feeding is supported by the detection of multiple hotspots and the fading lobe  ~30 mas (~40 pc) to the southwest in a different position angle from the main jet body. According to the evolution modeling of extragalactic radio sources (Kaiser & Best 2007), a critical requirement for a CSO to evolve beyond the ISM–IGM boundary (typically 1–3 kpc) of the host galaxy is that the jet remains supersonic and maintains a laminar flow. Compared to high-power high-velocity sources, low-power low-velocity CSOs such as OQ 208 can easily develop turbulent jet flow after losing a significant amount of their momentum flux and kinetic energy during their interactions with the ambient ISM. Frustrated CSO radio sources with turbulent jet flow would not evolve into large-scale symmetric FR II-type radio galaxies.


Acknowledgments

The authors thank the anonymous referee for helpful comments. This work is supported in part by the National Basic Research Program of China (973 Program) under grant Nos. 2009CB24900 and 2013CB837901, the Science & Technology Commission of Shanghai Municipality (06DZ22101), the China-Hungary Collaboration and Exchange Program funded by the International Cooperation Bureau of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS) and the Strategic Priority Research Program (XDA04060700) of the CAS. F.W. thanks the JIVE/ASTRON Summer Student Program and for the hospitality of the JIVE. S.F. was supported by the Hungarian Scientific Research Fund (OTKA K104539). The authors thank Ger de Bruyn for discussions about low-frequency variability of OQ 208. This research has made use of the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database (NED), which is operated by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, under contract with the National Aeronautics and Space Administration. The National Radio Astronomy Observatory is a facility of the National Science Foundation operated under cooperative agreement by Associated Universities, Inc. The MOJAVE project is supported under National Science Foundation grant 0807860-AST and NASA-Fermi grant NNX08AV67G. This research has made use of the United States Naval Observatory (USNO) Radio Reference Frame Image Database (RRFID). The University of Michigan Radio Astronomy Observatory is supported by funds from the NSF, NASA, and the University of Michigan.

References

Online material

Table 1

Model-fitting parameters.

All Tables

Table 1

Model-fitting parameters.

All Figures

thumbnail Fig. 1

Total intensity image of OQ 208. Panel a) shows the 2.3-GHz VLBI image, displaying a double-component morphology. Panel b) shows the tapered 2.3-GHz image. The extended emission at  ~30 mas west of the primary structure is likely a relic radio emission resulting from the past activity a few thousand years ago. Panels c) and d) show the 8.4 and 15 GHz images. Each mini-lobe is resolved into two hotspots. Between the hotspots NE1 and SW1, a knotty jet is detected.

Open with DEXTER
In the text
thumbnail Fig. 2

Variability of VLBI components of OQ 208. a) Total flux density variability of OQ 208 observed with the UMRAO 26-meter radio telescope: 4.8 GHz (black), 8 GHz (red), 14.5 GHz (blue). The sum of 15-GHz flux densities of the VLBI components (see Table 1) is represented by green symbols indicating that  ~15% is missed due to lack of short uv-spacings. b) Temporal variations of the flux densities of VLBI components. The flux densities are derived from the model-fitting results listed in Table 1. Two vertical lines mark the peak epochs of NE1 (around 1998.313) and SW1 (around 2003.313). To clearly show the variability behavior of SW1, the flux densities of SW1 have been multiplied by a factor of 10. c) Variation of the 15-GHz flux density of the hotspot NE1 with the component size. The flux density of NE1 experienced a slow rise before epoch 1998.313, followed again by a sharp decline until epoch 2005.473 followed by a slow decline. The component size constantly increases during the whole period. d) Temporal variation of the spectral index of the NE lobe. The spectral indices are calculated from the 15-GHz MOJAVE data and 8-GHz RRFID data at close epochs. A sharp jump of the spectral index occurs around 2006, after which the spectral index steepens significantly.

Open with DEXTER
In the text
thumbnail Fig. 3

Relative proper motions of VLBI components with respect to the brightest hotspot NE1. The proper motions of the VLBI components are determined by linear fits to the separations as a function of time. The angular separation rate is calculated as μ(J1) = −0.034 ± 0.001 mas yr-1, μ(SW1) = 0.027 ± 0.002 mas yr-1, and μ(SW2) = 0.022 ± 0.002 mas yr-1. The hotspot NE2 does not show significant proper motion.

Open with DEXTER
In the text
thumbnail Fig. 4

Relative right ascension and declination of the VLBI components. The primary hotspot NE1 serves as a reference position.

Open with DEXTER
In the text

Current usage metrics show cumulative count of Article Views (full-text article views including HTML views, PDF and ePub downloads, according to the available data) and Abstracts Views on Vision4Press platform.

Data correspond to usage on the plateform after 2015. The current usage metrics is available 48-96 hours after online publication and is updated daily on week days.

Initial download of the metrics may take a while.